Short Answer
Local results depend on the searcher's location, the exact query and the time of the search, among other factors. Two grids taken from different points, with different keywords or on different days, will legitimately disagree. Comparisons are only meaningful when location, query and time are held constant.
Location
Proximity to the searcher is a major local factor, so the same business ranks differently across a service area.
Query
Small wording changes, such as adding “near me” or a neighborhood, return different result sets.
Time
Results change through the day and across weeks as competitors, reviews and listings change.
Context
Device, signed-in state and personalization can also shift what a person sees. Grid tools control for some of these factors, but not all.