Methodologies / Advanced Labs Methodology 17

Decision Provenance Engineering

The Decision Object is the organizing concept. The methodology is used in PMO & Compliance Governance.

KATHLEEN REYNOLDSEXECUTIVE GOVERNANCE | INCIDENT COMMANDWritten By Kathleen Reynolds Advisory
Read This Methodology As Text

A decision must be reproducible from what was available at the time, not reconstructed from later knowledge.

The Stages

  1. Define. Specify the decision, affected parties, time horizon, material downside and falsifiable claims. Here, an organization must preserve the rationale for a high-consequence decision despite shifting systems, staff and evidence. The decision object is defined first.
  2. Authenticate. Separate observed evidence, unverified inputs, estimates and validated results; retain source and cutoff. The temporal evidence cutoff is preserved: what was known, assumed and approved at the original time.
  3. Challenge. Construct the strongest rival hypothesis and identify discriminating evidence. The strongest rival is recorded with the decision, so a later reviewer sees what was weighed and why it lost.
  4. Compare. Evaluate reversible, conditional, deferred and full interventions against a documented baseline. Competing alternatives are captured beside the chosen course, not discarded once the decision is made.
  5. Authorize. Assign a human or governing body with actual decision rights; record conditions and exception triggers. Authority is confirmed and recorded independently of the recommendation.
  6. Observe. Measure outcomes, error and unintended consequences without changing the original forecast vintage. Execution and exceptions are linked to the decision they carry out, and outcomes are tracked.
  7. Reconcile. Preserve amendments, contradictory events and subsequent decisions as linked but distinct records. New evidence arrives later. The revised decision is a new version linked to the original, and it does not erase what was known, assumed and approved at the original time.

What It Does Not Claim

  • A perfectly sealed record may preserve a mistaken decision. Provenance establishes traceability, not correctness.
  • The identifier cannot substitute for authentication, and a sealed record does not prove that the underlying judgment was correct.