Methodologies / Signature Methodology 07

Evidence-to-Decision Provenance

The Lineage Chain is the organizing concept. The methodology is used in Legal Operations and Server-Side Conversion Engines.

KATHLEEN REYNOLDSEXECUTIVE GOVERNANCE | INCIDENT COMMANDWritten By Kathleen Reynolds Advisory
Read This Methodology As Text

Every material claim is linked to its authenticated source, time, uncertainty, contrary material and the action it authorizes, so the decision can be traced.

The Stages

  1. Define The Decision & Burden Of Support. Name the decision and how much support it needs. Here, a client disputes whether a deliverable was accepted.
  2. Inventory Primary Sources. List the original records and who holds them: a signed agreement, a CRM note, an email and a later objection.
  3. Separate Fact From Assertion. Sort each item into fact, assertion, inference, assumption or unknown before anything is concluded.
  4. Build The Claim-to-Source Graph. Connect each claim to the records behind it: the acceptance standard, the timing, and who actually sent and received.
  5. Test Contradictory Evidence. Bring the later objection in, and check whether the sources are truly independent of each other.
  6. Build Alternatives With Uncertainty Disclosed. Lay out the possible positions and say how sure each one is.
  7. Preserve A Reviewable Rationale. Record why the position was taken and what new evidence would reopen it.

What It Does Not Claim

  • A technically intact file may still be unreliable, and a source graph can create false confidence if the original collection is incomplete.
  • It is not a substitute for rules of evidence or legal advice.